J M Coetzee's Foe

                       Thinking Activity

• Comparative and critical analysis of Daniel Defoe’s ‘Robinson Crusoe’ and J. M. Coetzee’s ‘Foe’

In comparative and critical studies first we introduce both Daniel Defoe’s ‘Robinson Crusoe’ and J. M. Coetzee’s ‘Foe’. 

This Blogspot is in response to the thinking activity on J. M. Coetzee’s Foe . This thinking activity task is assigned by Megha Ma'am. I am going to write down a BlogSpot on J. M. Coetzee’s ‘Foe’. 

•  Daniel Defoe’s ‘Robinson Crusoe’

             Daniel Defoe, born in 1660 in London, England, was a versatile writer, journalist, and pamphleteer whose works made a significant impact on English literature. Defoe's literary legacy is particularly notable for his pioneering role in the development of the novel as a distinct literary form. His most famous work, "Robinson Crusoe," published in 1719, stands as a seminal piece of adventure fiction and has left an indelible mark on the literary world.

         ‘Robinson Crusoe’ by Daniel Defoe and first published in 1719, stands as a timeless masterpiece in the realm of adventure literature. This enduring classic chronicles the extraordinary journey of a mariner shipwrecked on a deserted island and his remarkable survival against all odds. Through the character of Robinson Crusoe, Defoe weaves a compelling narrative that explores themes of isolation, resilience, self-discovery, and the triumph of the human spirit. Robinson Crusoe has had a profound influence on literature and popular culture. It is considered one of the earliest novels in the English language, setting a precedent for the adventure genre. The novel has inspired countless adaptations, including films, television series, and stage plays. Moreover, it has influenced other literary works, sparking discussions on survival, human nature, and the essence of civilization.

        Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe  continues to captivate readers worldwide, offering a compelling exploration of the human spirit's resilience in the face of adversity. Through Crusoe's extraordinary journey, Defoe delivers timeless lessons on survival, self-reliance, and the enduring power of hope. As readers navigate the pages of this iconic tale, they are reminded of the indomitable strength that resides within every individual, echoing Crusoe's enduring message of determination and survival against all odds.

• J. M. Coetzee’s ‘Foe’

           J.M. Coetzee born on February 9, 1940, in Cape Town, South Africa, is a literary titan whose works have left an indelible mark on the world of literature. His insightful exploration of themes like apartheid, colonialism, power, and morality has earned him numerous awards and a reputation as one of the most significant writers of contemporary fiction.

Coetzee grew up in a bilingual and academic household, displaying early signs of his future literary prowess. He pursued his education at the University of Cape Town and later obtained a Ph.D. in English from the University of Texas at Austin. His academic background profoundly influenced his writing style and intellectual depth.

J.M. Coetzee's novel Foe was published in 1986. It stands as a provocative and inventive reimagining of Daniel Defoe's classic work, ‘Robinson Crusoe’.  Coetzee's narrative takes the story into unexplored territories, challenging traditional literary norms and questioning the nature of storytelling itself.

 

‘Foe’ introduces us to Susan Barton. She is  a woman marooned on a desolate island. Stranded and desperate to return home, she encounters Cruso, a mute man, and Friday, a native man. The story, thus, mirrors the familiar elements of Defoe's original narrative. However, Coetzee's novel takes a sharp turn by introducing a new character: Foe, a writer.

Susan was eager to tell her story and find a way back home  seeking Foe's assistance. Foe takes charge of narrating Susan's experiences, reshaping them into a marketable story for public consumption. Throughout the novel, the characters grapple with issues of authorship, power, and the inherent colonial nature of storytelling.

One of the most significant departures from Defoe's tale is the character of Friday. In ‘Foe’ Friday is portrayed as a man capable of speech but chooses not to communicate. This deliberate silence becomes a powerful symbol, highlighting the suppression of indigenous voices during the colonial era.

•  Comparative and critical analysis of both Novel : 

 

            When  comparing both Novels ‘Robinson Crusoe’  and ‘Foe’.  It becomes evident that while Defoe’s work celebrates individual resilience in the face of isolation, Coetzee’s novel delves into the complexities of human relationships, power structures, and the ethical dilemmas of storytelling.

          ‘Foe’ challenges the reader to critically examine historical narratives, offering a fresh perspective on the familiar tale, making it a compelling and essential read for those interested in the nuances of postcolonial literature. Coetzee uses Susan's self-awareness and reflective writing style to depict this position. This self-reflection allows Coetzee to write from a neutral perspective, neither fully active nor passive, symbolizing his own ambiguous identity as a white male writer in South Africa. 

           Susan rejected the authority associated with his white male identity due to its connection with the abuse of power. He identifies with Susan's lack of authority as an unsuccessful author, aligning himself with her vulnerability. Through Susan's voice, Coetzee criticizes colonialist and humanist discourse, exposing its flaws and acknowledging his own complicity in it.

           ‘Robinson Crusoe’ by Daniel Defoe and ‘Foe by J.M. Coetzee, while both rooted in the theme of survival on a deserted island, offer vastly different perspectives on human experience. In this comparative analysis, we will delve into the intricate layers of these novels, exploring the similarities and disparities in their portrayal of isolation, power dynamics, and the complexities of human relationships.

         ‘Robinson Crusoe’ was about a guy named Robinson Crusoe who gets stuck on an island. He learns to survive by himself, which shows human resilience. In ‘Foe’ a woman named Susan is stranded on an island too. It focuses on the emotional challenges of being alone and how it affects her. ‘Robinson Crusoe’ , Crusoe is the boss of the island. He makes decisions, controls everything, and showcases the power of one person in a challenging situation. 

         In ‘Foe’  who has the power to tell a story. It explores how different voices are suppressed, challenging the idea of who gets to control narratives. Friday has a voice but chooses not to speak. This silence highlights the historical silencing of indigenous voices during colonization, adding depth to the story. ‘Foe’ questions the ethics of storytelling. It’s like a story within a story, where characters debate who gets to shape the narrative. It challenges the truthfulness of historical storytelling.

            In ‘Robinson Crusoe’ Crusoe forms a bond with Friday, a native he meets on the island. Their relationship represents understanding and cooperation between different cultures. 

      

Conclusion

‘Robinson Crusoe’ and ‘Foe’ both explore survival, power, and relationships, but ‘Foe’ adds layers by questioning the ethics of storytelling. While ‘Robinson Crusoe’ focuses on individual strength, ‘Foe’ dives into the complexities of power dynamics and the stories we choose to tell. Both books teach us valuable lessons about human nature and the intricacies of communication and control.

Words : 1141